YouTube Long Video V/S Shorts Highest Earning Comparison In 2025

Introduction

There are two main ways of content creation on YouTube

1. Long videos: Videos of more than 10 minutes in length are called long videos
2. Shorts videos: Videos of less than 60 seconds

Both formats have their own advantages and challenges, but which format is the best in terms of earning? In this blog article, we will compare the earnings of long videos and shorts, which format earns more money and how to choose the right format for your channel. We are going to give information about all this. Read this blog article completely and if you like this blog article, then definitely share it with your YouTuber friend.

What is YouTube Long Video

Long videos are YouTube’s traditional power format which are more than 10 minutes long. This format is ideal for educational content tutorials reviews and documentaries.

Advantages of Long Videos :-

More Monetization:-

1. Videos longer than 10 minutes are required for YouTube monetization
2. More earnings through Adsense

Long Watch Time :-

1. Long videos retain audience for a longer time which is liked by YouTube algorithm

Sustainable Traffic:-

1. Long time traffic retention through SEO options

Challenges of Long Videos :-

1. More Time and Effort:- Making long videos takes more time for shooting editing and SEO
2. Audience Retention:- Motivating viewers to watch the video for 10 to 20 minutes is the biggest challenge
3. Limitations of Monetization:- YouTube’s monetization rules say that earning is possible only after 1000 subscribers and 4000 watch time, cannot earn before that

Google launches Gemini 2.5 Pro with AI Update Before I/o :- Read More 

What is YouTube Shorts

YouTube Shorts are videos of less than 60 seconds which are in a vertical format like Tik Tok. This format is ideal for entertainment viral videos and short stories.

Benefits of Shorts:-

1. Rapid growth:- Training videos on Shorts go viral quickly and long videos do not go viral quickly.
2. Less time creation:- It takes less time to create a 60-second video.
3. Brand collaboration:- It is easy for brands to create short promotional videos.

Challenges of Shorts:-

1. Monetization limitations:- Direct earnings through YouTube Shots are limited.
2. SEO optimization:- Shorts get low ranking in search engines.
3. Retention challenges:- Short videos end quickly which leads to low audience retention.

YouTube Long Videos V/S Shorts Earnings Comparison

A. Through Monetization :-

Format	Main monetization methods	Earning potential
Longer videos	Adsense, Brand sponsorships, Affiliate marketing	Longer watch time
Shorts	YouTube Shorts Fund Brand calibration	Medium Fast viral

B. Estimated Earnings :-

Long Videos :-

1. ₹50 to ₹150 per 1000 views Adsense
2. ₹50000 to ₹150000 per one million views

Shorts less than 60 seconds :-

1. ₹10 to ₹30 per 1000 views from Shorts Fund
2. ₹10000 to ₹30000 per one million views

C. Which format gives faster growth :-

Shorts :-

1. Chance of going viral quickly
2. Easy start for new creators

Long Videos :-

1. Steady traffic for a long time
2. Audience loyalty from in-depth content

How To Earn With YouTube Long Videos

A. Earning through Adsense :-

Adsense Ads in long videos :-

1. Free roll mid roll post roll ads
2. Low cost based earning

B. Brand sponsorship :-

Collaboration with brands :-

1. Sponsorship video product placement
2. Example “Promotion of a brand in tech review”

C. Affiliate marketing :-

Earning through links :-

1. Can earn commission 2% to 3% through Amazon Flipkart CG Affiliate
2. Example use this product and get 10% discount, link is given in description

D. Channel membership and super chat :-

Membership and super chats :-

1. $5 to $10 per member
2. Earning from super chat in live streams

E. Merchandise sales :-

Created your brand :-

1. T-shirt mug or digital product
2. Through YouTube merch store

Secret YouTube SEO Tips Boost Your YouTube Channel :- Read More 

How To Earn With YouTube Shorts

A. YouTube Shorts Fund :-

YouTube’s own money earning program :-

1. Earning with more than 1000 views
2. ₹10000 to ₹30000 on 1 million views in India

B. Brand Collaboration :-

Brand Collaboration through Shorts :-

1. Attracting branch due to fast virality
2. ₹5000 to 1 lakh rupees per video for new creators

C. Affiliate Marketing :-

Affiliate links in short videos :-

1. Through Amazon Flipkart or Click Bank
2. Example Earn ₹1000 cheaply

D. Cross Platform Promotion :-

1. Promotion on TikTok Instagram Reels from Shorts
2. Sending audience to YouTube channel
3. Increasing subscribers and watch time

E. Direct Monetization :-

1. Earning apart from YouTube
2. Through Paytm copy Buy me a copy here
3. Example Liked our video ₹50 Make a donation of

YouTube Long Video V/S Shorts which Format Earns The Most

A. Earning through Adsense :-

Long Videos :-

1. ₹50000 to ₹150000 per one million views

Shorts Videos :-

1. ₹10000 to ₹30000 per one million views

B. Earning through Brand Collaboration :-

1. Long Videos :- ₹50000 to ₹500000 per video as per the brand
2. Shorts Videos :- ₹5000 to ₹100000 per video

C. Affiliate Marketing :-

1. Long Videos :- Earn commissions in wide range like 1% or 5%
2. Shorts Videos :- Short promotional videos

D. Long Term Traffic :-

1. Long Videos :- Give long term traffic through SEO optimization
2. Shorts :- Drop in traffic after going viral

Which Format Is Right For You

A. For new creators:-

1. Shorts videos:- To gain audience quickly and go viral in less time
2. Long videos:- For stable traffic

B. For already established creators :-

1. Long videos:- Stable earnings and audience loyalty
2. Shorts videos:- To gain audience

C. For fixed income:-

1. Long videos:- For monetization and SEO
2. Shorts videos:- For going viral quickly

YouTube Long Videos V/S Shorts Videos Who will be Successful in The Future

A. YouTube’s strategy:-

1. Focus on Shorts:- To promote YouTube Shorts
2. Support for Long Videos:- For detailed content

B. Use of AI and automation :-

1. Long Videos:- Issue options from AI tools given script tube big
2. Shorts Videos:- Fast creation with CANVA and Capcut

C. Audience preference :-

1. Long Videos:- Those looking for in-depth information
2. Shorts Videos:- For entertainment and fast virality

How To Make YouTube Long Videos V/S Shorts Videos

A. Use of both formats :-

1. Video + Shorts :- Long videos give SEO traffic and short ones give faster growth

B. Fixed strategy :-

1. Long videos :- Two videos a week
2. Shorts :- One to two shorts daily

C. Personal contact to audience :-

1. Long videos :- Comments and Q&A
2. Shorts :- Duet reaction videos

How To Working YouTube Algorithm In 2025 :- Read More 

YouTube Long Video V/S Shorts Video How To Increase Your Earnings

A. Strategy for Long Videos :-

1. Keyword Research :- Google Keyword Planner & Tube Big
2. Thumbnail Design :- Canva, Adobe Express
3. Seo Optimization :- Meta Tag Description

B. Strategy for Shorts :-

1. Trending Audio :- Take from TikTok Instagram
2. Thumbnail Design :- Canva and Pictory.ai
3. Responding to Comments :- Audience Engagement

C. Both Formats :-

1. Long Videos :- Detailed Information
2. Shorts :- Fast Growth

10 Best Tools for Monetizing YouTube Long Videos V/S Shorts Videos

Tools for Long Videos :-

1. Tube Badi :- SEO Optimization
2. Canva :- Thumbnail Designing
3. Descript :- Video Editing
4. Google Keyword Planner :- Keyword Research
5. Mail Champ :- To stay connected and engaged with subscribers

Tools for Shorts :-

1. CapCut :- Fast Video Editing
2. In Short :- Video Editing
3. JPR :- Automated Sharing
4. Later :- Social Media Scheduling
5. Canva :- Thumbnail Designing

FAQ

Q1. Which format earns more

ANS :- Long videos (via Adsense)

Q2. Can you earn from shorts

ANS:- Yes but less than long videos

Q3. Can I use both formats

ANS:- Yes Grow audience through long videos and shorts

Q4. Which format is best for SEO

ANS :- Long videos with keyword description tags

Q5. Is there monetization from shorts

ANS :- Yes through YouTube Shorts Fund

Conclusion

Long videos are more profitable for earning on YouTube but shorts are useful for rapid growth and most important to retain your audience You can earn through both mediums but you can earn more from long videos

If you have any question related to YouTube long video shorts then comment below